What Gift Card Should You Give to the People On Your Holiday List?

December 19, 2025

The top gift on holiday shopping lists is fun to give and receive.

It may be surprising to learn that the people on your holiday shopping list are okay with you giving them a gift card. In fact, they may prefer one! The InComm Payments 2025 Holiday Report bears this out. Our annual consumer survey found that gift cards are the top item holiday shoppers expect to purchase this season.

Why are holiday shoppers planning for gift cards?

There are several important reasons why gift cards make an effective holiday gift:

  • Choice – Gift cards give the recipient the freedom to choose what they want, satisfying their personal preferences.
  • Value – In uncertain economic times, gift cards deliver buying power, enabling the recipient to get what they really need or want.
  • Opportunity to splurge – A gift card enables the receiver to treat themselves to a fun, unplanned purchase that they normally wouldn’t make.

The days of gift cards being disparaged as a “lazy gift” or a “cop-out” are fading. In our annual Holiday Report, 91% of consumers said that gift cards can be just as thoughtful as other gifts. What’s more, 92% of consumers said that they would rather receive a gift card than return a gift that’s not right for them.

What’s driving holiday shoppers to give gift cards?

The InComm Payment 2025 Holiday Report found that almost half of holiday shoppers would rather give gift cards to everyone on their list. They cited several key reasons:

  • Time savings – Gift cards are easy to find and purchase in stores, as well as wrap and give to the recipient.
  • Money savings – As the price of many products fluctuates due to tariffs and other factors, the cost of gift cards remains consistent, which helps holiday shoppers stay within budget.
  • Stress relief – With gift cards, there is less worry about price and whether the recipient will like their gift. Buyers can also avoid the return and exchange process that happens when a gift is unwanted.

What gift card should you give?

There are generally three types of gift cards you can consider for family, friends and acquaintances on your holiday list:

Best Buy, Starbucks, and Target (closed-loop) gift cards

Closed-Loop

A gift card limited to redemption on the specific brand identified on the card (e.g., specific restaurant, gaming platform or clothing store). When you know a person well enough to know both their interests and their brand preferences, consider a closed-loop gift card for their favorite brand. Many consumers prefer gift cards for stores where they often shop, making the gift feel more useful and personal to them.

Open-Loop

These are all-purpose cards whose funds can be spent anywhere the network is accepted. (e.g., Mastercard®, Visa®, American Express® gift cards). It’s the card to give when you don’t know a person’s interests very well, as they can use it virtually anywhere, on anything they want.

Zift Zillions of Gifts™ Multi-Brand Card

Multi-Brand

This card is redeemable for a wide range of digital gift cards on the product’s website (e.g., Zift Zillions of Gifts™ Gift Cards). The Multi-Brand gift card offers a versatile gifting solution, centered around a specific theme such as dining, shopping or gaming. Because the card gives the recipient multiple spending options, it is the ideal gift for a person you know fairly well (e.g., care givers, coworkers) but not their specific brand preferences.

Where to find the gift cards people are wishing for?

Whether giving a physical or digital gift card, The Gift Card Shop is your go-to holiday shopping destination. The Gift Card Shop is a secure, convenient website offering the perfect gift card for family, friends, coworkers and all your acquaintances — all in one place. You’ll find over 200 gift cards, including:

For businesses in a festive and giving spirit, they can buy gift cards in bulk at The InComm InCentives Shop. Whether sending to partners, employees or customers to celebrate the holidays, the website offers easy-to-use ordering and fulfillment solutions. The InComm InCentives Shop provides a vast selection of physical and digital gift cards, and special discounts on volume orders, too — all backed by expert customer service.

There is plenty to like about gift cards this holiday season. As our annual holiday report pointed out, gift cards are the #1 item shoppers expect to buy this season. The report also revealed that shoppers like buying them as gifts, and that recipients are very happy to receive them. For the giver, its convenience, practicality, and affordability are unmatched. For the recipient, its flexibility and ease of use is unquestioned. Let it be said that gift cards make everyone’s holiday a happy occasion.

The Gift Card Shop Logo

To find gift cards for everyone on your holiday list, visit The Gift Card Shop.

To explore bulk gift card options for your business, visit The InComm InCentives Shop.

Prefer to keep reading?
Check out The InComm Payment 2025 Holiday Report:

Visa® Gift Card is issued by Sutton Bank, Member FDIC, pursuant to a license from Visa U.S.A. Inc. Visa is a registered trademark of Visa, U.S.A. Inc. Cards may be used in the U.S. and District of Columbia everywhere Visa debit cards are accepted. Terms and conditions apply. See Cardholder Agreement for details.
Mastercard® Gift Card is issued by Sutton Bank, Member FDIC, pursuant to a license from Mastercard. Cards may be used in the U.S. and District of Columbia everywhere Mastercard debit cards are accepted. Terms and conditions apply. See Cardholder Agreement for details.
American Express® Gift Cards are issued by American Express Prepaid Card Management Corporation (PCMC). Terms and conditions apply. See Cardholder Agreement for details.
Zift Zillions of Gifts cards are issued by Pathward®, N.A., Member FDIC. Brand options and amounts may vary and are subject to change. Merchant trademarks are the IP of the respective merchants and are used with permission. No cash or ATM access. Terms and conditions apply. See Cardholder Agreement for details.
Cards are distributed and serviced by InComm Financial Services, Inc., which is licensed as a Money Transmitter by the New York State Department of Financial Services. NMLS ID# 912772.

You May Also Be Interested In